Should You Replace Carpeted Stairs with Wood?

If your staircase is still covered in carpet from 1997, you’re not alone—and you might be wondering if it’s time for an upgrade. Carpeted stairs can feel cozy, sure, but they also trap dirt, wear down fast, and let’s be honest… they’re not doing much for your home’s style.

That’s why more and more New Jersey homeowners are making the switch to sleek, durable wood treads. It’s not just about looks (though the “wow” factor is real)—wood stairs are easier to clean, more modern, and can even boost your home’s value.

So, is swapping that carpet for wood the right move for your home? Let’s break it down.

Carpet vs. Wood Stairs: Pros and Cons

When it comes to updating your staircase, the big debate is usually this: carpet or wood? Each has its fans, and each brings something different to the table. But if you’re staring at your scuffed-up, stained carpet wondering if it’s worth the switch, here’s a side-by-side look at what you’re really gaining—or giving up.

The Case for Carpeted Stairs

Carpeted stairs are all about comfort. They’re soft underfoot, quiet when someone’s running up and down (especially if you live with early risers), and they offer a little extra cushion in case of trips or falls—something that’s especially helpful in homes with toddlers or elderly family members.

But all that coziness comes with a price. Carpet traps dust and allergens like a magnet, shows stains almost instantly, and wears down quickly—especially in high-traffic spots like stairs. That plush look can turn dingy fast, no matter how often you vacuum.

Why Homeowners Are Switching to Wood Treads

Wood stairs bring a totally different vibe: clean, timeless, and upscale. If your home leans modern, classic, or anywhere in between, hardwood steps instantly elevate the space. And here’s some good news — you don’t need to rebuild your entire staircase to get that look. In most cases, it’s as simple as replacing the treads and risers. The structure stays. The finish transforms.

They’re also a smart investment. According to Bob Vila, hardwood floors (stairs included) are one of the most attractive features for homebuyers. They last longer, they add value, and they’re a design choice that rarely goes out of style.

Worried about slipping? That’s where a carpet runner can be a perfect compromise. You get the clean edges and polished look of wood, with added comfort and traction right down the middle.

What Are the Downsides of Replacing Carpeted Stairs with Wood?

Of course, wood stairs aren’t all sunshine and resale value. There are a few things to weigh before you rip up that carpet.

First up: cost. Wood treads and risers are an investment. They typically cost more than a basic carpet job—especially if you're using solid hardwood or high-end finishes. But that upfront price comes with a longer lifespan and fewer maintenance headaches down the road.

Then there’s the slip factor. Smooth wood can be slick, particularly if you wear socks or live with little ones who treat the stairs like a racetrack. But don’t worry—this isn’t a dealbreaker.

With options like carpet runners, anti-slip tape, or built-in grip finishes, slippery stairs are a solvable problem.

Is It Worth Upgrading Carpeted Stairs to Wood?

If you’re on the fence about upgrading, here’s the real talk: yes, it’s an investment—but one that pays off in more ways than you’d expect.

Wood stairs don’t just look better. They hold up better—day after day, year after year. No more frayed carpet edges, stains that never come out, or endless vacuuming. Just clean lines, solid surfaces, and a finish that actually lasts. And when guests walk in—or more importantly, when buyers come knocking—it shows. Hardwood stairs say, “This home is cared for.”

It’s also one of the most overlooked upgrades when it comes to adding value. According to StairSupplies, updating your staircase—especially the treads—can instantly modernize your space and increase resale potential.

And the best part? You don’t need to gut your stairs or start from scratch. Most homeowners only replace the treads and risers, which means you can get a whole new look without a full-blown renovation.

So is it worth it? For most homeowners, the answer is yes—especially if you’re looking for a smart upgrade that looks great and lasts.

How Much Does Stair Tread Replacement Cost in NJ?

If you’re thinking about ditching that old carpet for clean, timeless wood treads, your next question is probably: “What’s it gonna cost me?” Fair question—and the answer depends on a few key factors.

For most homes in New Jersey, stair tread replacement costs between $1,500 and $3,000, but that number can swing higher depending on your choices. Here’s why:

• Materials matter. Solid hardwood (like oak or maple) is the gold standard—beautiful, durable, and long-lasting. But it’ll cost more than engineered options. You’ll also pay more for custom finishes or non-standard tread sizes.

• Stair shape counts. A straight run of 10 steps is going to be simpler (and cheaper) than a curved or split staircase with landings or turns.

• Removal isn’t free. If your stairs are carpeted, pulling that out and prepping the surface adds time and labor.

• Labor in NJ runs higher. It’s no secret—local stair contractors here charge more than the national average. But with stair safety and finish work, this is not the place to cut corners.

According to HomeAdvisor, the cost to replace carpeted stairs with wood treads in New Jersey typically runs between $100 and $200 per step—based on material choice, labor, and staircase design.

Common Misconceptions About Replacing Carpeted Stairs with Wood

If you’ve been putting off a stair upgrade because it sounds like a hassle, you’re not alone. There are a few persistent myths that keep homeowners from moving forward—even when wood treads are exactly what their home needs. Let’s clear some of that up.

Myth #1: You can just install wood treads over carpet. It sounds convenient, but it’s not safe—or legal. Carpet compresses and shifts, which means wood treads won’t sit level or secure. To meet building code and avoid a major trip hazard, the carpet has to come out first. Every time.

Myth #2: It’s a major renovation. Not even close. Your stair frame stays. What’s being upgraded are the treads and risers—the parts you see and walk on. In most cases, it’s a straightforward project that doesn’t involve tearing anything down or closing off your home for days.

Myth #3: Wood stairs are always loud. Yes, wood can be noisier than carpet—but there are ways to manage that. A well-installed staircase with quality materials won’t creak and groan, and if you want to soften the sound even more, a runner down the middle solves that without hiding the wood.

Still unsure how this all plays out? You can always reach out with questions—we’ll walk you through what to expect and help you figure out what makes sense for your space.

Ready for a Change Underfoot? Here’s the Bottom Line

There’s something about a freshly upgraded staircase that instantly changes the feel of a home. When you pull up that worn-out carpet and replace it with clean, solid wood treads, it’s not just a cosmetic improvement—it’s a shift in how your home lives, lasts, and welcomes people in.

Carpeted stairs can feel soft and familiar, sure—but they wear fast, stain easily, and hold onto years of use in ways that even deep cleaning can’t undo. Wood, on the other hand, gives you longevity. It gives you something solid underfoot. Something that actually adds to your home’s value instead of quietly dragging it down.

That doesn’t mean it’s the right move for everyone. Budget matters. Safety matters. So does timing. But if you’re already dealing with worn carpet, cleaning struggles, or a staircase that feels like an afterthought, wood treads are one of the most impactful upgrades you can make—without tearing your house apart.

And it doesn’t have to be complicated. Most projects don’t require a full staircase rebuild—just smart planning, skilled installation, and the right materials for your space.

If you’re curious what that could look like in your home, reach out here. We’ll talk you through it, answer your questions, and help you decide if now’s the time to make the switch.